So Long Mike Dunbar
After two average years leading Minnesota's transition to the spread offense, offensive coordinator Mike Dunbar has resigned, according to the Star Tribune.
Some have speculated about Dunbar's future after Tim Brewster hired Tim Davis away from Alabama to coordinate a power running game. We saw flashes of Davis' impact on the offense at the Insight Bowl. But we also saw moments when two offensive ideologies collided, resulting in offensive miscues.
We'll have more on Dunbar's departure later, but for now, what direction would you like this offense to go?
0 recs |
19 comments
|
Comments
I’d like to see a spread based offense that integrates power running options for goal line/short yardage situations and to shake things up (I like the 3-running back set). I’d also like to see more of David Pittman passing after being lined up next to the quarterback (so the defense has 2 passers to key on instead of 1) and more deep pass routes. Why not put Weber and Gray in the backfield together with Pittman in motion? Defenses would be dizzy and confused. Basically, let’s keep the defense frustrated and tentative with many different looks and precise execution of plays a la Boise State.
Buck Bravo
My bet is Davis assumes the OC position.
Buck, I like your ideas stated above.
Maroon and Gold Headquarters: The Daily Gopher
lets see Hasan Lipscomb
2 1000 yrd rushers next year please :)
back to the glory years of Mason run offense, but combined with
even better next year Roof defense.
by goldybobblehead on Jan 6, 2009 11:22 AM CST reply actions
Remember me, PJS?
I’m the guy who questioned Dunbar’s position not only a couple hours after Davis was hired, but also during our conversations during the Insight Bowl.
Ahem, ahem. I’ll take some credit my way. Dunbar agreed with me – there’s no way he and Davis could co-exist after Brewster undercut him with Davis.
And now, honestly, was the 1-11 season worth going through if we’re going to be reverting to a pro-style running game which Mason ran while he was here? I feel for Mason – Brewster is going to struggle to win games next year with the tough schedule, and he’s reneged on his promise to run the spread offense in order to stay in games next year.
Buck Bravo – why not put Moses Alipate in the backfield too and run the quarterback wishbone : )? The key, as always with football, is the offensive line. If the line is good you can do almost anything you want schematically. A poor line will leave your QB out to dry, won’t open running lanes, and won’t pass protect for receivers to get downfield. The O-Line coach took the fall and Davis looked mediocre in coaching the line in the Insight Bowl. If the lines aren’t shored up, Brewster will not make it to year 4.
you're right...I left out Alipate
Good call JG. The Gophers will have Weber, Gray, Pittman, and Alipate who are all talented passers. They could probably have three of them on the field at once, if not occasionally all four. Gray and Pittman run like wide receivers, and Weber and Alipate aren’t slow either. I’d hate to be the defensive coordinator facing those possibilities. Hopefully Carufel and Wills will help strengthen the line next year.
Buck Bravo
Yes, JG!
You were one of the people I was referring to! Good call. I have a post ready in my head piggy-backing on some of your arguments concerning the transition to the spread and the apparent new thought process. Though feel free to do a fanpost on the subject and I’ll bump it up top.
Maroon and Gold Headquarters: The Daily Gopher
I'll do what I can.
I cannot believe your recent post. Ted Roof as well? What is the next step now? I think we really need to call Mike Shanahan and Tony Dungy. Heck, they’re available!!
Dear Mother of God...
If we revert to what Mason was running, Brewster should be pistol whipped. And anyone who advocates said change should get the same treatment. I think Buck Bravo’s got the right idea. There are ways to mix the spread and the power run game. I also think that would be the way Brewster wants to go, knowing that the spread works for recruiting and that he wants to have his offense move the pile when they need to.
by WhiteSpeedReceiver on Jan 6, 2009 12:18 PM CST reply actions
I'll throw a name out there
Tony Franklin, the guy Auburn hired this year to institute a spread then fired him halfway through the season.
He is an offensive guru and creative. He was also at one point named one of the top 10 recruiters in the South. This is the type of guy Brewster will be looking for.
what you say here can, and will, be used against you
I like that choice...
..a lot. However, we have to hope that our situation wouldn’t blow up the way it did at Auburn.
Some bad news
I’ve heard through the blog grapevine that Roof may be headed to Auburn. If it is true, very unfortunate, as I thought things were looking up on D with him.
Not too surprising
Dunbar seems to have rumors follow him about how well he gets along with others (at least I recall that from his last 2 postings).
I agree with those who say keep the spread, mix in some real running sets with QB under center and that in the end the OL is the key to any scheme.
Another Thought
Is Dunbar (or Roof if MinnMarch is right) responsible for any of our Verbals? Wonder if those 2 leave whether we might see any attrition from our current recruits.
off the top of my head
I wouldn’t think losing Dunbar should have any material affect on offensive recruits. Roof might be a different story. For instance I know Taikwon Paige who committed this weekend commented how having the defensive coordinator spend a lot of time recruiting him was a big deal to him. So obviously Roof has a relationship with one of our top recruits.
what you say here can, and will, be used against you
Needless to say...
…a horrible time to lose a defensive coordinator. This could lead to a couple surprise de-commitments to Auburn on Signing Day or earlier, if the reports of Roof leaving are true.
Spread and Coordinators
I would like to see us still employ the spread. I think the reason we had such troubles on short yard situations was because of the ineffectiveness of our offensive line and not having the best running backs. I do not want to see us go pack to the pro set.
We are getting the athletes we need to run the spread, we just don’t have it all together yet. Our main problem is the offensive line. We should be much better at the running back position with Bennet returning last year. BTW…can he get a medical redshirt for last year and get another year of eligibility?
Someone already hinted at my idea, but I think we should look out west for our offensive coordinator. We should look at Boise State or Utah coordinators to develop game plans that fit with the spread offense and our new speedy and athletic players.
I’m still saddened that McNeal chose Clemson over Minnesota.
I'm with you rencito
the problem in short yardage had far more to do with offensive line than our spread formation. I’m all for occasionally lining up under center at appropriate times, but for the most part I’m a fan of the spread.
A more creative play book would be nice and seeing improvement throughout the season would be good as well, but the spread will stay. This notion of pro sets, power I, wishbone or whatever is just not going to happen under Brewster.
I’ll say it again…TONY FRANKLIN! He is regarded as a very good recruiter, everywhere he has been (even Auburn) his system was picked up quickly and improvement was seen immediately, he is creative, has developed QBs and would make this offense much more dynamic.
what you say here can, and will, be used against you
Athletes
Like I said, the spread needs the right personnel. Brewster can’t turnover the roster in one year. It is going to take four full years for him to get his right guys in there. Even though we still missed out on McNeal (Floyd wasn’t Brewster’s fault, he arrived too late—the fact that Minnesota was even in the picture at the end is a testament to Brewster) we are still getting better guys than Mason could get.
Franklin may not be a bad choice. After all, Roof was a retread himself.
Keep the spread
We need to keep the spread… If we don’t, any athletes on the offensive side of the ball will leave us way before the signing period. So I agree with the first poster – use the spread as the primary option between the 10’s and use power formation on short-yardage and goal line situations.
I don’t mind Dunbar being gone as our offense stagnated big-time, but want to see a coordinator that can run the spread and be willing to work with Davis on the running game. Probably won’t lead us to a big-name coordinator, but could give us a young, creative mind who is energenic and can recruit.

by 











