No Chance for a Signature Win in 2009
The Gopher football program and Tim Brewster could have used a signature win in 2009. Defeating either California, Penn State, or Ohio State would have influenced the future course of the program. The sentiment of the fans would have been different today, even if the record were only 7-4 instead of 6-5.
But wouldn't a win versus #15 Iowa be a signature win? No.
Don't be mistaken, Iowa is a good team. They have an excellent defense, a top tier coach, and one of the better offensive lines in the country. In fact, I predicted them to win the Big Ten championship before the season started. A win would be sweet revenge for last season's 55-0 route of the Gophers in the Metrodome, but it would not be a signature win.
The bottom line is that outside of Minnesota and Iowa fans, nobody else cares about this game. Iowa isn't playing for a Rose Bowl berth or a Big Ten championship. Both teams are perennial second tier Big Ten programs. Iowa is currently at the peak of the program's potential, and Minnesota is somewhere above the valley of the program's worst season in 2007.
Minnesota and Iowa fans can both banter about "Hate Week," debate the superiority of rural Iowan versus urban Minnesotan culture, and covet a little metal trophy of a pig, but nobody else cares. To New Yorkers, both teams are from flyover country. To Southerners, we're all still just "Yankees." To Californians, anyone who lives in Minnesota or Iowa is just missing out.
I don't expect the Gophers to even keep the game close tomorrow. I'll still watch the game, just like I occasionally watch the Powerball ping pong balls roll on out as I look at my ticket with a feeling of false hope. Don't get me wrong, the sensation of false hope is definitely worth a dollar now and again. If the improbable...nearly impossible, were to happen and the Gophers win, it will give the Gophers bragging rights but not the signature win that they so needed this year.
0 recs |
1 comment
|
Comments
Disagree
I’m going to respectfully disagree, for a couple of reasons:
1) Iowa is a quality program that has gained national respect this season. Although a loss to Minnesota would make them a ho-hum 9-3 team, they still stand to go to a BCS bowl with a victory.
2) Beating Wisconsin and Iowa is very important to me and to most fans of Gopher football. For any school, beating your top two rivals would be very high on a program’s list of goals and also for metrics by which to judge a head coach.
3) An argument could easily be made that a home win over Cal or a road win at Penn State would not have been as meaningful for Minnesota football this season as a win at Iowa. The Hawkeyes already sit ahead of the Nits in the Big Ten and BCS standings and Cal has been in and out of the top 25 since beating the Gophs in September.
4) Personally, a win tomorrow would be the BIGGEST the Gophers could possibly have this season. Although I would personally give Minnesota only the slimmest chances of victory, a win would still a) deal Iowa a devastating blow to a 2009 season that once included realistic chances for a Nat’l Championship and b) give Minnesota a great chance at a January bowl game (Alamo).
Usually, I find myself pretty solidly in the “Buck Bravo Camp,” but not today I guess…
5) Even if you are viewing the outcome of a possible upset tomorrow only from a national perspective, the win would be very significant. Sure, beating No. 8 Cal in September would’ve garnered the team more national buzz, but the Bears have proven themselves incapable of staying power. Sure a win over Wisconsin would’ve made the Gophers 4-1, but that single game still would not scramble the Big Ten standings compared to what they are today.

by 











