Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Ohio State And Florida Target 2013 Receiver Recruits

An early look at the depth chart - Offense

The season is just over three months away.  Incoming freshmen have yet to make their way on to campus, players on suspension are still up in the air, injuries are a big wildcard and as we all know as Gopher fans ANYTHING is possible over the next few months.  But let's start with a look at a projected 2-deep and since posting is light around here I'll split this into two posts and I'll begin with the offense. 

Mind you, this is not a firm prediction and I'm sure I have a few starters incorrect (especially along the OL).  This is intended to be a conversation starter, let's debate who will be starting where along the OL, who will be the work-horse running back and most importantly who will back up Jon Hoese at full back?

Pos Name YR
QB Adam Weber SR

  MarQueis Gray SO
RB DeLeon Eskridge JR

  Duane Bennett JR
FB Jon Hoese SR

  ??
WR Da'Jon McKnight JR

  Troy Stoudermire JR
WR Brandon Green JR

  Hayo Carpenter SR
TE Eric Lair JR

  Tiree Eure JR
RT Jeff Wills SR

  Ed Olson rFR
RG Matt Carufel SR

  Ryan Orton JR
C DJ Burris SR

  Ryan Wynn JR
LG Chris Bunders JR

  ??
LT Dominick Alford SR

  Brooks Michel rFR

 

QB - this one was easy, especially since Brewster announced that Adam Weber would be the starter.  Everyone has an opinion and it is usually a strong opinion on this position, but when projecting who will actually be starting (not who should be or who you want to be) this one is clear-cut.  From a 2-deep perspective it becomes even more interesting when you factor in the argument that MarQueise Gray should be playing wide receiver.  Then things get interesting.  But for now this is the depth chart with Moses Alipate a worthy third-string.

RB - This position is maybe the most interesting battle on the roster.  Eskridge and Bennett seem to be completely even heading into fall camp, but then we add some promising freshmen into the mix. Neither of the returning backs have Gopher Nation super excited.  They are both solid backs who do some things well but also neither of them have all conference or game changing ability.  If we go through the season with these guys splitting the vast majority of the carries I expect our running game will be OK.  If any freshman emerges I believe it will be Lamonte Edwards, but it just as easily could be Donnell Kirkwood or Devon Wright.  There is some reason for hope and optimism with this group of freshman backs, but they are true freshmen and there is no telling how they will adjust to Big Ten football or whether they'll be physically ready to handle it.

FB - I believe Hoese is a very solid full back.  He plows through the line in short yardage situations and his blocking has been adequate.  It is impossible for me to venture a guess as to who would fill that role should Hoese get injured.

WR - This position has been a frustrating one for me and I think they escaped a lot of the offensive criticism last year when they should not have been given a free pass.  There are some talented receivers on the roster but they all need to take some significant steps forward in 2010, particularly in the area of getting separation from defensive backs.  But this is all for another post, today we are talking about depth charts.  Da'Jon McKnight was the one guy who actually took advantage of Eric Decker's injury last year.  After going the first eight games of the year without a receptions, McKnight caught 17 balls for 311 yards in the final 5 games after Decker was lost for the season.  If I had to pick a #1 for the upcoming season it would be McKnight.  The returner with the most catches and yards is Troy Stoudermire, who I really like. The kid has break-away ability but has yet to show that ability off.  Once again I think the Gopher offense will try to get the ball in his hands but this is the year he needs to flash some of that speed and turn catches into touchdowns.  Brandon Green will also get a lot of snaps, but he too needs to start performing better on the field.  He runs clean routes but really needs to gain more separation to be a more open target.  Hayo Carpenter is the poster child for not living up to expectations (realistic or otherwise).  With a year in the program behind him, maybe he has a breakout senior season and adds a dynamic play-maker to this offense.  The opportunity is there, someone needs to step up.  Bryant Allen, Xavier Brandon and incoming freshman Marqueis Hill have a shot at also contributing.

TE - I think you'll see a lot of both tight ends listed.  I won't claim to be a great TE mind but both are big targets and should be solid in both blocking and catching passes over the middle.

OL - and this is where it gets interesting.  This group was awful last year and took a lot of deserved heat.  They basically are all back and one would hope improved.  Based on the spring game they did do a much better job in both the running and passing game, but a spring game isn't exactly a good barometer of how they'll fair against USC and Ohio State defensive fronts.  You can use a pen for the right side starters.  Matt Carufel was our best lineman a year ago, for whatever that's worth and he'll be the game 1 starter at RG.  Jeff Wills is going to start at RT and the behemoth tackle looked a bit more agile during the spring game.  The rest of the line, both starters and backups, are just educated guesses.  As you know there were five incoming freshmen recruited for the OL.  The one with the best chance of contributing as a true freshman would be Jimmy Gjere.  But I for one hope they all redshirt and over the next few years develop into a great group of linemen.  The 2010 line?  Well that may be the biggest question mark of the year.

 

Thoughts?  Comments?  Is my depth chart way off?

Comment 7 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

There should be alot of competition for starting positions once fall practice begins.

There are only a couple of players who are guarnteed a starting spot. Hopefully the competition will push all the players to improve.

by MinnesotaCatFan on May 26, 2010 4:36 PM CDT reply actions  

Why don’t you have any of the freshman on the depth chart.

by Frod0 on May 26, 2010 9:34 PM CDT reply actions  

Where

do you suggest freshmen should play? The only place they should be considered is at RB. If you’re suggesting true freshman O-linemen, LOL. Wherever a true freshman O-lineman would line up would instantly become the weak link of the team and would be exploited like crazy by our opponents.

by JG2112 on May 27, 2010 6:59 AM CDT up reply actions  

yeah, I'm not sure where they would go

really at any position true freshman have a hard time stepping in right away in the Big Ten (even for Minnesota). I talk about the freshman running backs, Marquise Hill at WR and Jimmy Gjere along the OL; but I don’t see any of them cracking the 2-deep.

Deep down I have a gut feeling that Lamonte Edwards will be a stud and may see significant time this fall, but that’s a total guess and right now you would have to list Bennett/Eskridge at RB.

what you say here can, and will, be used against you The Daily Gopher

by GopherNation on May 27, 2010 9:20 AM CDT up reply actions  

If

Edwards is able to come in and outperform Bennett and Eskridge, that will be a good thing on the one hand, obviously.

On the other hand, it’ll make you wonder about our RB coaches’ ability to develop guys who will have been in the program for at least 3 years.

Seriously, on the true freshman idea, do you really want Gjere, at 18 years’ old, having to block Clayborn, Binns, Heyward, the Wisconsin beasts, the Penn State D-line and LBers, and Nick Perry, et al from USC? No chance. Let him perfect his technique and ability and he can contribute in 2011.

by JG2112 on May 27, 2010 9:38 AM CDT up reply actions  

no I do not "want" that

he’s likely the only one with even a chance to outperform the current suspects based on his size, athleticism and guru approval. Highly unlikely, but the only one with even a chance.

But I for one hope they all redshirt and over the next few years develop into a great group of linemen.

what you say here can, and will, be used against you The Daily Gopher

by GopherNation on May 27, 2010 11:02 AM CDT up reply actions  

and

DB/DE being potentially outplayed by a true freshman may just say more about their ability than anything else. I’m assuming those freshman backs only play if they turn out to be very talented backs. DE/DB are not blessed with superior talent, doesn’t matter who is coaching them.

Maybe the coaching staff is mediocre, maybe the talent is mediocre, maybe the OL is mediocre.

what you say here can, and will, be used against you The Daily Gopher

by GopherNation on May 27, 2010 11:09 AM CDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Minnesota Golden Gophers sports--Usually analytical, sometimes snarky.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Epson003-2_small
Gophers @ Nebraska
47487
New Uniforms!
M_nerf_small
B1G/PAC Matchups
Small
Can Minnesota get to a bowl game in 2012?
Ishot-2_small
A modest proposal to eliminate 15 bowl games and send their mediocre teams home for the holidays
Mn_basketball_small
Big Ten Bloggers Pick'em Standings
Small
Minnesota Gophers Should be Happy to Have Jerry Kill
Small
Eat More (Bucknell) Bison

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Mn_basketball_small GopherNation

Imagescary7xfo_small Jeffrick

Img-20101223-00043_small JDMill

Editors

Imgres_small PJS

Bigbuck_small Buck Bravo

Dsc02076_small JG2112