Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Sob City: Clippers Swept By Spurs

Poll: How are you feeling about Jerry Kill?

Okay. I thought that this would be a good time to gauge the fan base's opinion of Jerry Kill. Naturally, you have to question the timing of this poll, but I'll be surprised if anyone notices this in the next couple of days.

I think this is the perfect time for this poll because Minnesota just beat Iowa (a trophy game) but is in the midst of a less-than-stellar season that likely won't end in a bowl. So, the results should not be riding off an all time high or an all time low, as it might have at an earlier point in the season.

The poll will stay open until the end of the season.

If you look at the poll, you might be thinking that I added too many options, but I think I've captured all the varying degrees of how people feel about Kill as coach. It's not a yes or no type of question anyway.

In case you're wondering where you fit in, here's a run-down of what every option means:

I'm confident he's the right guy.
You're in the same boat with the president (Kaler) and the athletic director (Maturi), and you think this hire was an excellent one. A couple of losing seasons are never pleasant, but that's the way of the world sometimes. The program needed to make a statement about where it stands with Jerry Kill, and the contract extension was absolutely the right call. You think Kill's the guy to finally take Minnesota to the Rose Bowl.

I want him gone. We can do better. We are Minnesota!
You didn't like the hire, and you don't like Kill now. Your opinion is that Minnesota deserved a bigger name coach either because a) that's what Maturi said would happen, b) that's what was needed, or c) Minnesota is still in a BCS conference, dammit. You think Minnesota could land a big name coach if it tried hard enough, and offering Kill the job was a way of accepting defeat.

I'm on board with him now, but if there isn't serious improvement next year (i.e. going to a bowl), then he'll be on my hit list.
Your expectations for Jerry Kill were pretty high—and still are. You're really not happy with how the season has been going so far, but he's still the head coach and will be for the next couple of years. While you can stomach one poor season, that's all you're giving him. You can't wait three or four years, and you expect the turnaround to happen fast. You have some patience with Kill, but it's wearing thin.

I think he was a good coach at the MAC level, but he's in over his head now.
You fully respect Jerry Kill as a coach, but it takes a special guy to make Minnesota successful, and Jerry Kill is not that guy. You also think his seizure disorder is becoming a serious obstacle for both him and the program. While you can admit that Jerry's ultimately a good guy, he can't quite handle all the pressures of a program like Minnesota. Ultimately you think a different coach is needed.

Not really happy. A coach's job is to win. Instead he makes excuses and blames his players, when he should just admit whatever it is he's doing wrong.
Regardless of what Kill inherited, you think that the buck stops at the head coach and, even in his first season, there's no excuse for what's happened. Kill was supposed to be a program rebuilder, but he's clearly not doing a good enough job coaching—and the season is evidence of that. You almost wish he didn't give press conferences, and you won't be impressed with Kill until he delivers.

Jerry's come into a tough situation. Any coach would be struggling with what Minnesota has right now. I give him the benefit of the doubt.
You aren't happy that the start of the Jerry Kill era isn't spectacular, but you remember Kill's first press conference, and he said this wasn't going to be easy. You appreciate his frank words, and you're in this for the long haul, but maybe were hoping that the haul wouldn't be so long. Still, you recognize that, whatever the reason, the team Kill inherited was in bad shape, but he's capable of turning it around…eventually.

Why are we even asking this question? It's his first year!
To you, this poll is completely pointless. You can't judge a coach by his first season, and you don't really understand why everyone keeps questioning a guy that the university just hired. Regardless of whether you support Kill or not, it's way too early to tell at this point whether the hire is a good one. You'd like to think that Minnesota didn't make a bad hire, but that's a discussion for Kill's third or fourth year, not his first.

Poll
How are you feeling about Jerry Kill?
I'm confident he's the right guy.
50 votes
I want him gone. We can do better. We are Minnesota!
3 votes
I'm on board with him now, but if there isn't serious improvement next year (i.e. going to a bowl), then he'll be on my hit list.
3 votes
I think he was a good coach at the MAC level, but he's in over his head now.
4 votes
Not really happy. A coach's job is to win. Instead he makes excuses and blames his players, when he should just admit whatever it is he's doing wrong.
2 votes
Jerry's come into a tough situation. Any coach would be struggling with what Minnesota has right now. I give him the benefit of the doubt.
34 votes
Why are we even asking this question? It's his first year!
22 votes

118 votes | Poll has closed

Editors of The Daily Gopher retain the right to remove posts deemed excessively offensive or grossly inappropriate. Keep it clean and don't be mean.

Comment 10 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

There was no extension

that was his original contract. Let’s not propagate Souhan’s laziness.

"My love for Jerry Kill knows no bounds." - Jeffrick

by TheEvilProfessor on Oct 31, 2011 11:01 AM CDT reply actions  

In a way it was an extension

because it had been reported last December that Kill agreed to five years. Souhan’s spin on the recent developments was that Kill was being rewarded for failure—which is obviously incorrect.

by Meager Reader on Oct 31, 2011 12:57 PM CDT up reply actions  

if you have to preface it with "in a way"

It isn’t. At least that should not be the go to upfront description of what it was. He was working under a loose set of agreed upon terms based upon a rough offer sheet which was not a signed contract. You cannot extend something that was not signed.

I know it seems like semantics…but it’s not. Renegotiation or counter-offer or offer amendment are much more accurate terms that already exist in our lexicon…let’s use them. Facebook and twitter already dumb down our communication abilities without needlessly propagating poorly constructed statements written by columnists looking for website hits.

"My love for Jerry Kill knows no bounds." - Jeffrick

by TheEvilProfessor on Oct 31, 2011 3:40 PM CDT up reply actions  

It would have been interesting to see what the results would have been prior to the Iowa victory. I voted for option 6 which I would have either way, but I was surprised with the way that the season has gone that at this point only 3 votes were negative as Kill as a hire. Either we are all optimists or the win over Iowa has us all feeling better than before.

I felt like we had improved from Purdue to Nebraska as we seemed we were out talented against Nebraska while the Purdue game felt like we did not know what we were doing. The way the team played against Iowa we would be a 4 or 5 win team if we played that way throughout the season. Here’s to hoping that we see continued improvement over the final 4 games.

by MNSportsGuy on Nov 1, 2011 5:39 PM CDT reply actions  

I was kind of surprised about that as well.

I originally was going to post this a few weeks back, but I figured that morale would be at an all time low, and everybody would vote negative. So I figured I’d wait until MN beat Iowa to post it. The upside being that it was a victory in the midst of a losing season, and a particularly satisfying victory at that, so there were both positives and negatives.

The poll is still open until the end of the season, so I suspect that we’ll have a few more negative votes once Minnesota hits a few more losses. But apparently right now a lot of people don’t just think Kill can eventually make the program competitive, they think he’ll take MN to the Rose Bowl—as Kaler and Maturi do. Now that’s optimism!

by Meager Reader on Nov 1, 2011 7:20 PM CDT up reply actions  

who thinks Kill will take us to the Rose bowl

I don’t recall that as an option. That would be some extra strength Kill-aid. We might get lucky one year and put together a really solid team and get a win we otherwise wouldn’t and have the teams in front of us stumble a couple of times. If Wisconsin can lose to both MSU and OSU this year after how well they were playing, then anything is possible.

"My love for Jerry Kill knows no bounds." - Jeffrick

by TheEvilProfessor on Nov 1, 2011 9:51 PM CDT up reply actions  

It's supposed to be the first option.

There’s a bit of overlap in the positive and negative choices, and I try to make them distinct, because people support or don’t support Kill for different reasons and in varying degrees.

But generally the first one was fully confident to the point where they’re echoing Maturi and Kaler: “I’m confident he’s the right guy.” And losing seasons don’t really bother them (at least not initially) because the hire was made with the long-term in mind—and the ultimate goal is Pasadena.

I thought option six (“Jerry’s in a tough situation”) would be more popular because that was both hopeful and unsure, and willing to give Kill time. Option one is fully on the Kill-wagon.

by Meager Reader on Nov 1, 2011 11:08 PM CDT up reply actions  

ah

I have to admit that I chose that one, but probably wouldn’t if it was written “Jerry Kill will be the one to take us back to the Rose Bowl!”

I think he’s the right guy to build our program, but it’s a far cry to start chanting Rose Bowl.

"My love for Jerry Kill knows no bounds." - Jeffrick

by TheEvilProfessor on Nov 2, 2011 7:31 AM CDT up reply actions  

yeah, that's why I wrote the descriptions

because people would have been like “how is #1 any different from #6?” Well, the difference is the level of confidence.

by Meager Reader on Nov 2, 2011 2:39 PM CDT up reply actions  

7% negative

I think it is safe to say that number would have been closer to 50% before the Iowa game. The team had not shown anything to that point, looked disorganized, too many penalties, couldn’t stop anyone, and out offense sputtered at best. Watching this team or having a root canal would have warranted serious debate.
Then we played Iowa……

Marqueis turned into a QB during the Iowa game. He is throwing with more accuracy, the line is protecting him better, and he is making good decisions for the most part. Enter hope for the future again…..and next year the players get to play under the same system….what a novel concept.

by Narby on Nov 10, 2011 6:12 PM CST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Minnesota Golden Gophers sports--Usually analytical, sometimes snarky.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

47487
B1G Conference FB schedules for 2015 and 2016 released
Daily_logo_small
What does the Vikings stadium deal mean for Gopher football?
47487
B1G Homecoming Kickoff Times announced
83217-125958-hawkeye_super_small
Gophers Host a Kegger!
47487
Big Ten announces prime-time TV schedule
47487
President Kaler announces VCU athletic director as AD finalist
Small
Hoops Season In Review
Small
Gophers Hockey Preview
Small
Frozen Four Preview
Small
Gophers 2013 Basketball Prospectus

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Mn_basketball_small GopherNation

Imagescary7xfo_small Jeffrick

Img-20101223-00043_small JDMill

Editors

Imgres_small PJS

Bigbuck_small Buck Bravo

Dsc02076_small JG2112